In contemporary Indonesia, the narrative of success and prosperity often skips over the silent majority—millennials who are wrestling with socioeconomic challenges. Despite the external facade of a thriving nation, many Indonesian millennials are silently battling the triple threat of burdensome income taxes, irresponsible parenting, and skyrocketing living costs. Recent policy shifts limiting fuel subsidies further complicate the landscape, amplifying financial strains, and adding to existing burdens. Adding fuel to the fire, the recent controversies involving Mario Dandy, other notable corruption cases, and the controversial funding for the new capital city, Ibu Kota Nusantara, bring to light the misuse of public funds by government officials, further eroding trust in public institutions.
The Heavy Hand of Income Taxes
For many young Indonesians, the advent of their professional careers means the beginning of another reality check: income taxes. This taxation system, while theoretically beneficial for the collective infrastructure and services, often becomes a daunting hurdle for millennials striving to build their financial stability. With an average tax rate hovering around 30% for higher-income brackets, millennials find a significant portion of their earnings channeled away from their personal aspirations.
A survey conducted by IPSOS Indonesia highlights that 65% of millennials feel overburdened by taxation. For many, this means deferring or even giving up on dreams such as homeownership, higher education, or starting a business. The systemic pressure manifests in a form of economic limbo—earning enough to be taxed heavily, yet not enough to feel the tangible benefits of their labor. This creates a paradoxical situation where increased earnings result in a proportional increase in financial strain.
The Compounding Nature of Taxes
The burden does not end with income taxes. Millennials find their post-tax earnings further pinched by a variety of other taxes imposed on goods and services. This compounding nature of taxes creates an additional layer of financial burden for those living solely on their salary.
- Value-Added Tax (VAT): The 11% VAT, applied to most goods and services, means that every purchase millennials make is subjected to an additional cost. This tax affects basic necessities, digital services, dining out, and even health care and funeral services. Yes, the Indonesian government took benefits from the sick, dying, and dead.
- Luxury Goods Sales Tax (LGST): For millennials aspiring to purchase items like cars or electronic gadgets, the LGST can be prohibitive. This tax further dampens the ability to save for future investments or leisure activities.
- Vehicle Taxes: Owning a vehicle in Indonesia involves multiple taxes, including the annual vehicle tax and the vehicle acquisition tax. This is particularly burdensome for millennials who rely on personal transportation due to inadequate public transport systems.
- Real Estate Taxes: Aspirations of homeownership are further hampered by property taxes and the transaction fees on property purchases. Given the rising real estate prices, these taxes make acquiring property even more challenging.
- Excise Taxes: Applied to items such as tobacco and alcohol, excise taxes impact the cost of goods that, while not essential, form part of social and leisure activities. This further limits the disposable income millennials have for recreation.
These compounded taxes significantly reduce the net income millennials can actually utilize for investments, savings, or even day-to-day living.
The Impact of Irresponsible Parenting
Beyond financial pressures, a deeper societal issue looms large: the consequences of irresponsible parenting. Indonesia’s rapid modernization has drastically altered family dynamics. Traditional structures that once emphasized communal support are weakening. Some parents, overwhelmed or underprepared for the societal shift, struggle to provide the guidance and stability their millennial children need.
Irresponsible parenting can take many forms—from lack of emotional support and effective communication to financial irresponsibility. In extreme cases, millennials find themselves shouldering the burden of their parents’ debts or reckless financial behaviors. This phenomenon, often described as “sandwich generation” syndrome, places millennials in a double bind: taking care of their parents and their children simultaneously, with limited resources to manage both.
The Spiraling Cost of Living
Adding to the complexity is an ever-rising cost of living. Jakarta, Indonesia’s bustling capital, symbolizes this challenge with its escalating prices in real estate, basic commodities, and essential services. According to a recent report by the Indonesia Statistics Agency, inflation rates in major urban centers have consistently surpassed the average wage growth, squeezing millennials into tighter financial corners.
Rising educational costs further compound the problem. Higher education, once seen as a ticket to upward mobility, now increasingly resembles an insurmountable financial mountain for many. Even those fortunate enough to attain degrees often find themselves mired in student debt, entering a job market that struggles to offer satisfactory returns on their academic investments.
The Looming Burden of Fuel Subsidy Limitations
Compounding these existing issues is the government’s recent initiative to scale down fuel subsidies. For years, fuel subsidies have been a critical support mechanism for Indonesian households, making transportation and goods more affordable. However, as the government shifts towards reducing these subsidies to balance the national budget, millennials are set to face another wave of financial strain.
The reduction of fuel subsidies is expected to lead to increased transportation costs, higher prices for goods, and a ripple effect across the economy. For millennials, who are already navigating the precarious waters of high-income taxes and rising living costs, this change spells additional hardship. The linkage between fuel subsidy limitations and income taxes becomes apparent as millennials are forced to allocate a larger share of their taxed income toward essential expenses, leaving little room for savings or investments.
The Cases of Corruption Among Government Officials
The outrage sparked by the recent scandal involving Mario Dandy, the son of a tax officer flaunting a luxury Jeep Rubicon, is not an isolated incident. It is a vivid illustration of how taxes—meant to serve societal needs—are being misappropriated for the lavish lifestyles of certain government officials and their families. Such cases undermine the social contract between the government and its citizens.
Other notable corruption cases have further aggravated the public’s disillusionment. For instance, the e-KTP (electronic ID card) graft scandal involved multiple senior officials who embezzled funds from a nationwide identity card project. The misuse of billions of rupiah in public funds was supposed to be allocated for a crucial project to streamline public administration and improve services for citizens. The fallout from this scam was significant, casting a long shadow over public confidence in the government.
Similarly, the case of Setya Novanto, the former Speaker of the Indonesian House of Representatives, who was convicted in several corruption cases, highlights the endemic nature of corruption. His involvement in high-profile graft cases further exacerbates the perception that public officials are primarily serving their interests rather than the public good.
The Controversial Funding of Ibu Kota Nusantara
In addition to corruption, the ambitious project to move Indonesia’s capital to Ibu Kota Nusantara has elicited widespread concern about the misuse of taxpayers’ money. The total estimated cost for the new capital city is a staggering $33 billion. Critics argue that such an extensive expenditure is reckless, especially when it diverts funds from pressing needs such as healthcare, education, and infrastructure in existing urban centers that are already struggling to accommodate a growing population.
For many taxpayers, particularly millennials striving to achieve financial stability, the allocation of substantial funds towards the new capital project seems misaligned with their immediate needs. Despite the potential long-term benefits that the project might bring, the immediate financial burden imposed on taxpayers creates further economic strain. The escalating costs of this massive project compound the frustrations felt by a generation already struggling under heavy taxation and insufficient public services.
Government Apathy During Tech Layoffs
Adding to the sense of disillusionment is the government’s apparent indifference to recent tech layoffs occurring in various Indonesian startups. As the startup ecosystem in Indonesia expanded rapidly, many young professionals flocked to these opportunities, finding innovative and exciting career paths. However, the bubble burst in late 2022 and early 2023, leading to massive layoffs in major startups such as Gojek, Bukalapak, and Tokopedia. Thousands of millennials found themselves suddenly unemployed, adding to their financial anxieties.
Despite the scale of the layoffs and their impact on the workforce, the government response has been largely apathetic. Many ex-employees felt abandoned, as there were no significant interventions, support systems, or retraining programs initiated by the government to help them transition to new jobs. This sense of neglect stands in stark contrast to the relentless pursuit of taxes from these very same individuals, further exacerbating feelings of frustration and disenchantment.
Mental Health and Resilience
The confluence of these stressors inevitably takes a toll on mental health. High levels of anxiety, depression, and burnout are becoming the unwelcome companions of many Indonesian millennials. Yet, mental health remains a taboo subject, with inadequate support systems to address this burgeoning crisis. According to the Indonesian Psychiatric Association, the mental health landscape is underserved, with only 600 psychiatrists available for a population of over 260 million.
Despite these overwhelming hurdles, Indonesian millennials exhibit remarkable resilience. Initiatives spearheaded by this generation to foster entrepreneurial ventures, advocate for mental health awareness, and push for political reforms reveal an inherent strength and adaptability. Platforms such as social media serve as critical avenues for expression, solidarity, and mobilization.
Finding Hope in Unity
While the challenges are undeniable, the collective spirit of Indonesian millennials offers a beacon of hope. Grassroots movements and community-centric initiatives are knitting a tapestry of support, fostering environments where shared experiences can translate into shared solutions. From crowdfunding platforms helping alleviate financial burdens to educational workshops aimed at financial literacy, millennials are actively seeking—and creating—lifelines for one another.
Government intervention remains crucial. A re-examination of the tax structure, better support systems for mental health, policies aimed at stabilizing the cost of living, strategic planning around fuel subsidy reductions, and stringent measures to avoid misuse of tax funds are imperative. Engaging with millennials as critical stakeholders in the nation’s development could pave the way for sustainable progress.
In conclusion, the story of Indonesian millennials is one of resilience amidst adversity. Though besieged by heavy income taxes, the repercussions of irresponsible parenting, rising living costs, soon-to-be-felt fuel subsidy limitations, the ethical erosion highlighted by cases like Mario Dandy’s, e-KTP, Setya Novanto, the controversial funding for Ibu Kota Nusantara, and the indifference during tech layoffs, they continue to forge paths of innovation and solidarity. It is a clarion call for society at large to acknowledge and address these challenges, ensuring that the promise of Indonesia’s future is a shared reality for its most dynamic generation.
References and Sources
- IPSOS Indonesia Survey on Millennial Financial Burdens
- Indonesia Statistics Agency Report on Inflation and Wage Growth
- Indonesian Psychiatric Association: Mental Health Statistics in Indonesia
- The Jakarta Post, Kompas, and other news outlets covering the Mario Dandy case, e-KTP scandal, Setya Novanto’s corruption cases, and the Ibu Kota Nusantara project
- Government Policies on Fuel Subsidies: Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, Republic of Indonesia
- Coverage on Indonesian tech layoffs: Reuters, Bloomberg, and local news outlets
- Various grassroots initiatives and platforms mentioned in the article implemented by Indonesian millennials
Leave a Reply